Inside an avalanche
14 February 2006
Researchers from the Environmental Hydraulics
Laboratory at the EPFL (Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne) have built a
laboratory-scale avalanche simulator and are using it to build a complex fluid model
that will be able to follow the dynamic, non-equilibrium flow characteristic of
heavy snow avalanches. Coupled with
terrain-based testing and analysis in the Sionne
Valley of Switzerland, this physics-based
model will be an important step forward in our understanding of natural
disasters.
The winter
blanket of snow covering the Alps is
stunningly beautiful– and incredibly dangerous. In 2004-2005, 26 people died in
avalanches in Switzerland
alone. The victims range from occasional snow-boarders catching some powder
off-piste to backcountry ski guides with years of experience. In this
mountainous country, avalanches also pose a serious public danger. They can
bury people in their homes, cut off access roads or even flatten whole
villages. Scientists have put great effort into trying to understand the
physical mechanisms at work in avalanches, particularly in the domain of fluid
mechanics, in an attempt to improve our ability to predict and manage avalanche
danger. But progress is limited because the computer models that simulate
complex fluid movement are still quite rudimentary.
EPFL
professor Christophe Ancey, an expert in rheology, or flow phenomena, is
working to improve that situation. His team is building an installation that
will generate avalanches in the comfort of the laboratory. Unlike natural
avalanches, no two of which are alike, and all of which are quite uncomfortable
in scale and force, all the variables involved in these slides can be
controlled and the same avalanche can be studied repeatedly. The simulation
data will be used to construct a new numerical model capable of describing the
avalanche's dynamic behavior.
The
laboratory system Ancey is developing is based on the"dam-break" concept, in
which a viscous fluid is poured onto a steeply inclined plane. The blue ooze
flowing down the slope may not look like snow, but it deforms in the same way
an avalanche does, and shares the same physics – the highly complex,
non-equilibrium, non-linear flow that is characteristic of heavy snow and mud.
“No existing numerical model can reproduce what's happening in even this simple
setup," explains Ancey."As a first step, we need to be able to reproduce what
we observe, and with a model that takes only hours, not days, to run."
The model
Ancey constructs from the simulation data will be tested against reality in the
Sionne Valley in the Swiss Alps. There, in an
avalanche-prone area, the Swiss Federal Institute for the Study of Snow and
Avalanches has set up an amazing measurement station. A narrow wedge steel
construction, a 20m tall pylon and a bunker equipped with a variety of sensors,
video and Doppler radar have been placed in an avalanche track. As an avalanche
pounds down the mountainside, this equipment will collect a wide range of data.
Ancey's model will predict the progression of this same avalanche, and the
comparison with the data will reveal how well his model captured reality.
In this second, reality-testing phase of his project,
Ancey will collaborate with EPFL Professor Eduardo Charbon, who has developed
inexpensive new-generation sensors that can be placed across the snow surface
before the avalanche is triggered. These sensors will track the velocity inside
the avalanche, something that has never been possible before. The data can then
be analyzed and used to further improve Ancey's dynamic model.
“It is
important to change the way we understand, anticipate and manage natural
hazards," explains Ancey."Several elements interact to cause an accident or a
natural disaster. We often think that we can calibrate the models we use for
prediction using data from past events. But if we really want to be able to
predict what could happen, say in a scenario involving climate change, we must
be able to understand and explain the physics behind natural phenomena, instead
of just describing them. That's what we're doing in this research program."
In the long
run, Ancey's laboratory research, combined with the terrain-based testing and
analysis, will be used to develop a diagnostic system that can help
decision-makers better predict and prepare for these kinds of natural
disasters. Important political decision-making, such as approving development
in avalanche or flood-prone areas, requires accurate risk assessment. And the
physics-based approach being developed by Ancey will ultimately provide
decision-makers with a tool they can confidently use to evaluate the risk of
natural disaster in a variety of potential scenarios.
Launched in
2004, this project is financed by the EPFL and the Swiss National Science
Foundation, as part of the latter's National Center of Competence in Research
in Mobile Information and Communication Systems.
journaliste:
Florence Luy